The Truth About Zillow's "Zestimate"

Jill Springer • August 10, 2025

The Truth ...

.

Clickbait, Cash, and Leads:

How Zillow Chooses Agents by Money, Not Merit



For over 20 years, I’ve been helping buyers and sellers across the DFW Metroplex navigate every twist, turn, and market shift in real estate. I’ve learned that experience, attention to detail, and a personal touch aren’t just nice to have—they’re what truly make the difference.


And in that time, I’ve had more than a few up-close encounters with Zillow’s shortcomings. Sure, platforms like Zillow can be a convenient starting point, but I’ve seen them get it wrong—by a lot. I’ve handled transactions where their “Zestimates” missed the real market value by tens of thousands of dollars. I’ve seen listings where the photos, property details, and even the address belonged to a completely different home.


The bigger issue? Zillow doesn’t know your neighborhood, your home’s condition, or the unique features that influence its true value. Their algorithms pull from recent sales but ignore the details that matter most to buyers and sellers. And that’s not even their real business model—Zillow isn’t in the business of selling houses; they’re in the business of selling you.


Their product is your contact information, which they sell to real estate agents, lenders, and other industry partners. The agents who buy these leads aren’t vetted in any way—the only qualification is being able to pay for them. Some may be seasoned pros, but many are inexperienced or simply desperate for business.


I know saying this will ruffle feathers—especially among agents who pay for these leads—but they’re not my concern. My responsibility, and frankly the responsibility of every agent, is to uphold the highest standards and act in the best interest of the buyer or seller. Period. Zillow’s profit model depends on selling as many leads as possible, not on accurately valuing your home or connecting you with the right professional.


Even worse, I’ve seen these platforms used as the backdrop for rental scams, preying on people who didn’t know the listing they found was inaccurate—or completely fake.


That’s where I come in. My job isn’t to “sell you” on anything—it’s to give you the real picture so you can make confident, well-informed decisions. I dig into local market trends, analyze true comparable sales, and consider every unique detail of your home (or the one you want to buy) so the numbers we work with reflect reality—not just a guess from an algorithm.


When it comes to something as important as your home, “close enough” just doesn’t cut it. Before you make a move based on a “Zestimate,” give me a call or text at  817-658-2477 (or contact an agent you already have trust in.) I’ll make sure you have the facts, not just the fluff—so you can protect your investment and make your next step with confidence.



Jill Springer - Your Texas Realtor


Jill@JillsYourRealtor.com

www.JillSpringer.com

817-658-2477


By Jill Springer September 7, 2025
The Finer Details in a Contract 
By Jill Springer August 20, 2025
Zillow Wants to Dictate Your Home Sale—Why Sellers Should Push Back” 
By Jill Springer July 21, 2025
Open House Do's and Dont's for Buyers
Changes to how credit scores will be calculated will be implemented soon
By Jill Springer April 14, 2024
The introduction of new credit scoring models. Starting in 2025, new credit scoring models will be used by lenders to determine the creditworthiness of potential homebuyers
By admin May 22, 2020
Technology is helpful in so many areas of life, even real estate. Twenty years ago, if someone were moving across the country, they’d have to wait to buy a house until they arrived to start their new life, or they’d have to buy a home without seeing it in person beforehand. Both options would cause […]
By admin April 24, 2020
Saving money each month toward a long-term goal is increasingly difficult for most people. Even committed savers can get thrown off track when unexpected problems or opportunities arise. It can be difficult to envision how $200 a month can add up to a new home; the dream of home ownership continues to get pushed back […]
By admin October 9, 2019
If you are a first time home buyer or even a repeat buyer, you quickly realize that real estate has a language all its own. Understanding some of the lingo can help you navigate the process a little easier. By learning a few critical terms, you will be in a better position to ask the […]
By admin September 25, 2019
For generations, homeowners would buy a home for life. Working over the years to make the payments and celebrating the end of the 30-year mortgage were great milestones in the family. Today, few homebuyers expect to be in their home for longer than 7 years on average. Paying off a 30-year mortgage seems like an […]
By admin July 12, 2019
Are you ready to list your home for sale? One of the first questions you might have is, “how can I maximize my home value?” Every seller wants to get the best possible price for their home; fortunately there are ways to make sure your potential buyers see the true value of your property and […]
By admin July 12, 2019
Summer is upon us and home designers are hard at work showcasing the upcoming trends for 2020. This year, kitchen design shows are filled with new materials, patterns and colors as enthusiasts look for the latest trends and styles. As we leave the dark granite countertops behind, kitchens are getting lighter, brighter and more streamlined […]